Choosing a Method

Weighing Risks and Benefits

Which option is right for you? It depends on which method has possible advantages for you that outweigh the risks and possible disadvantages. This choice is different for everyone. For example, if you’re a single woman in your 20s, your priority may be preventing pregnancy and preventing sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). If you're a married woman in your 30s, you may be only concerned with pregnancy prevention.

Use the information in this section to help evaluate the different available methods of birth control and choose which one is right for you. Keep in mind that, while all birth control is intended to prevent pregnancy, some methods are more effective than others. In making your choice, it may be helpful to explore the effectiveness of these methods. Talk to your health care professional to determine which choices may be right for you.

Oral Contraceptives (The Pill)
Some oral contraceptives contain both estrogen and progestin and are called combination oral contraceptivesSperoff-2, pp. 30A, 31A, while others only contain progestin and are called progestin-only pills. Nakajima-2, p.65A

Advantages

  • Highly effective contraception 10. Berek, p. 250A
  • May increase menstrual cycle regularity 10. Berek, p. 259A
  • May decrease iron deficiencies and anemia due to blood loss 10. Berek, p. 259
  • May reduce the chance of developing ovarian and endometrial cancers Berek-10, p. 259A
  • May help protect against noncancerous breast tumors and pelvic inflammatory disease Berek-10, p. 259A
  • May decrease the risk of ovarian cysts and ectopic pregnancies Berek-10, p. 259A

Limitations

  • Increased risk of developing heart attacks, strokes, and blood clots, particularly in women who smoke Berek-10, pp. 251A, B, 253A, 254A, 255A
  • Irregular bleeding or breakthrough bleeding Carlson, p. 283A
  • Adverse effects may include headaches, breast tenderness, weight changes, excess hair growth or hair loss, nausea, and depression Carlson, pp. 283A, 284A
  • Daily action required44. Ortho Tri-Cyclen Lo PI, p 1 (Indication & Usage)
  • No protection against STDs49. FDA Birth Control p. 3

Barrier Methods (diaphragms, cervical caps, sponges, and male and female condoms)

Advantages

  • Provides effective contraception, with typical failure rates between 15% and 32% Trussell, p. 90A
  • Some methods may help reduce the risk of contracting some sexually transmitted diseases, and possibly cervical cancer Carlson, p. 81A
  • Among the safest methods Carlson, p. 81A
  • Among the least expensive methods Carlson, p. 81A
  • May help reduce the risk of acquiring pelvic inflammatory disease Berek-10, p. 238A

Limitations

  • Decreased effectiveness if not used consistently and correctly Carlson, p. 81B
  • Require a fair amount of regular effort Carlson, p. 81B
  • Often inconsistently used Carlson, p. 81B
  • Methods such as the cervical cap require fitting by a health care professional Carlson, p. 81C
  • Highest failure rate of contraceptive options other than "no method" Berek-10, p. 236A

Intrauterine Device (IUD)
A small, T-shaped plastic device inserted into the uterus by a medical professional to prevent pregnancy. 2. Mishell, p. 930

Advantages

  • Provides highly effective contraception Carlson, p. 318A
  • Can be used long term Carlson, p. 318B
  • No daily or coital action required Carlson, p. 319A

Limitations

  • Increases risk of developing pelvic inflammatory disease Mirena PI, p. 1F
  • May perforate the uterine wall Mirena PI, p. 1H
  • May cause some rare but serious complications that can render a women infertile Mirena PI, p. 1F
  • May cause menstrual cramps and excessive menstrual bleeding Mirena PI, p. 1I
  • Must be inserted by a medical professional Mirena PI, p. 1B
  • No protection against STDs49. FDA Birth Control p. 3

Sterilization (Vasectomy and Tubal Ligation)
A surgical procedure in which an individual is made incapable of reproduction. 7. Dorland’s Medical Dictionary, p. 1760

Advantages

  • Provides highly effective contraception, with 0.15% (male sterilization) to 0.5% (female sterilization) of women experiencing an unintended pregnancy within the first year Trussell, p. 90A
  • Causes permanent infertility Carlson, p. 82A
  • No need for any other form of birth control Carlson, p. 82B

Limitations

  • Exposes individual to risks of surgery Speroff-21, p. 847A
  • Is generally irreversible Carlson, p. 82A

Natural Methods
Withdrawal and periodic abstinence.42. Nakajima p. 140-147

Advantages

  • Most economical forms of contraception

Limitations

  • Effectiveness is highly dependent on the methods being used consistently and correctly4. Danforth’s Obstetrics & Gynecology, p. 554
  • No protection against STDs42. Nakajima, p. 141
  • Lack of reliability in estimating the fertile window 4. Danforth’s Obstetrics & Gynecology, p. 554-555; 42. Nakajima, p. 141

Transdermal Contraception
A transdermal contraceptive patch contains norelgestromin (a progestin) and ethinyl estradiol, andOrtho Evra PI, p. 1C works the same way as combination oral contraception. Speroff-23, pp. 943B, 945D

Advantages

  • Possible improved compliance due to the elimination of a daily regimen Speroff- pp. 23, 943A
  • Less fluctuation in estrogen and progestin levels with weekly change of patch than consuming a daily oral medication REF Nakajima-4, p. 70A
  • Avoidance of first-pass effect through the liver, with fewer adverse effects on liver parameters Nakajima-4, p. 70A; Ortho Evra PI, p. 1F

Limitations

  • Visibility of the patch Nakajima-4, p. 70A
  • Application site reactions Nakajima-4, 70A; Ortho Evra PI, p. 4B
  • Decreased contraceptive efficacy with increased body weight Ortho Evra PI, p. 4A
  • Increased estrogen exposure relative to OCs Ortho Evra PI, pp. 1A, B, 2B
  • Insufficient drug delivery if the patch becomes partially or completely detached and remains detached Ortho Evra PI, p. 5B
  • No protection against STDs49. FDA Birth Control p. 3

Vaginal Ring
The vaginal ring is a hormonal contraceptive that is inserted by the patient and left in place continuously for 3 weeks. NuvaRing PI, p. 18A; Nakajima-4, p. 77A

Advantages

  • Highly effective
  • No daily or coital action required NuvaRing PI, p. 18A
  • Avoids first-pass effect through the liver with less disruption of lipoproteins and less alteration of hepatic function Nakajima-4, p. 76B
  • Concentrates hormones in the uterus, which allows for use of lower doses of medication and potentially less frequent administration Nakajima-4, p. 76B
  • Hormones are rapidly absorbed, with the estrogen having a bioavailability of approximately 56%, which is comparable to oral administration, and the progestin having a bioavailability of approximately 100% NuvaRing PI, p. 2A
  • Compared with oral medication, causes less nausea and gastrointestinal disturbance, and less susceptibility to inadequate absorption if diarrhea occurs Nakajima-4, p. 76B
  • Compared with transdermal route, is more easily absorbed into bloodstream and is not stored in fat tissue Nakajima-4, p. 76C
  • Provides steady-state hormone levels that are easily achieved and less dependent upon patient compliance with daily or weekly medication administration Nakajima-4, p. 76D; NuvaRing PI, p. 2B

Limitations

  • Young patients may be unwilling to insert ring and leave in place for 3 weeks Nakajima-4, p. 76D
  • Woman and/or partner may feel ring during sexual intercourse NuvaRing PI, p. 15A
  • Occasional spontaneous expulsion can occur NuvaRing PI, p. 16A
  • No protection against STDs49. FDA Birth Control p. 3

Contraceptive Implants
Contraceptive implants are a "sustained-release" system that provides stable circulating levels of a progestin. Speroff-24, p. 950B; Implanon SmPC, p. 2A

Advantages

  • No daily or coital action required Implanon PI, p. 1A
  • Provide highly effective contraception Speroff-24, p. 954A
  • Provide long-term, rapidly reversible contraception Speroff-24, p. 953B
  • Can be used by women who have contraindications for the use of estrogen-containing
    contraceptives Speroff-24, p. 953B

Limitations

  • Cause unpredictable bleeding patterns; endometrium sheds at unpredictable intervals Implanon PI, p. 3A; Speroff-24, p. 953C
  • Require invasive procedure for insertion and removal, increasing costs Implanon PI, p. 7A; Speroff-24, pp. 953D, 954B
  • Visible under the skin Speroff-24, p. 953D
  • No protection against STDs49. FDA Birth Control p. 3

Contraceptive Injections
Contraceptive injections are a progestin-only contraceptive method administered every 3 months. Depo-PI, p. 21A; Speroff-24, p. 961E

Advantages

  • Easy to use; no daily or coital action required Speroff-24, p. 964A
  • Comparable efficacy to sterilization, intrauterine contraception, and implant contraception Speroff-24, p. 964A; Depo-PI, p. 6A
  • Free from estrogen-related effects Speroff-24, p. 964A
  • Not associated with compliance problems during the 3 months it is effective Speroff-24, p. 963C; Depo-PI, pp. 12A, 16A

Limitations

  • Contraceptive effect lasts 12 to 14 weeks; method not immediately reversible Depo-PI, p. 2A
  • May cause: Speroff-24, p. 964B
    – Irregular menstrual bleeding Depo-PI, p. 12A
    – Breast tenderness Depo-PI, p. 20B
    – Weight gain Depo-PI, p. 17A
    – Depression Depo-PI, p. 18A
    – Loss of bone mineral density Speroff-24, p. 966A; Depo-PI, pp. 1A, 9A
  • No protection against STDs49. FDA Birth Control p. 3